---

Posted by Anna on January 04, 2000 at 22:00:09:

In Reply to: banging heating pipes/absent super posted by Ian Penny on January 04, 2000 at 17:42:56:

: I live in Brooklyn, NY in a rent-stabilized brownstone with 11 units. For the last several years the landlord has refused to correct a problem with the heating system. Every winter the heat goes on early each morning and the pipes clang for an hour at a deafening level. This is not merely a problem of tilting the radiator or draining the pipes. It appears to be a structural problem involving corroded steam pipes that run from floor to ceiling in every unit. As a result it is impossible to sleep past 5:30 a.m., when the banging usually starts. I wanted to know what actions I could take. Does the problem amount to a violation of the covenant of habitability. Should I pursue a case in housing court to have the problem corrected. Can I have a plumber take a look at the problem and then deduct the cost of the etsimate or repairs from my rent?
*******************
It's probably not 'corroded pipes': it probably is bad pitch in the really big pipes in the basement. My friend has that problem: some really @#%%$ licensed plumbers installed an elbow upside down, the racket is deafening, the landlord (a coop) won't fix it. It wakes up the whole building if there was no heat overnight (otherwise it just wakes up the first two floors...) The colder the pipes, the louder the noise.

What you can do is organize your fellow tenants. Then together, if possible: Write letters to the landlord. Report the problem to both HPD and Dept of Buildings, boiler unit. File a complaint with DHCR, ask for a rent reduction. File an HP Action in Housing Court. Learn how to do all this on TenantNet Home.
*******************
: The other problem I am experiencing is that there is no live-in super in the building. Instead, tenants are given the number of the person who handles the garbage and who occasionally performs light maintenance. However, he ignores calls from tenants and will only respond to tenant complaints when the landlord directs him to. For instance, he did come by when my kitchen roof collapsed and I reported it directly to the landlord. However, he will not answer his beeper and he will not deal with problems such as leaky faucets, even when you ask him in person. There used to be a live-in super in the building but he was fired and the landlord rented out his apartment. Is it legal for the landlord not to have a super on the premises at an 11-unit building. Is it sufficient to have someone who will only respond to emergencies and will not answer tenant complaints directly? If this is not legal, can any action be taken by the tenants?
*******************
9+ units = live-in or -nearby Super required, on call to tenants 24/7: it's the law. See TenantNet Home, basic rights. Report to HPD and DHCR (ask for rent reduction for reduction of services).

Follow Ups:

---

Note: Posting is disabled in all archives
Post a Followup

Name    : 
E-Mail  : 
Subject : 

Comments:
: : I live in Brooklyn, NY in a rent-stabilized brownstone with 11 units.  For the last several years the landlord has refused to correct a problem with the heating system.  Every winter the heat goes on early each morning and the pipes clang for an hour at a deafening level.  This is not merely a problem of tilting the radiator or draining the pipes.  It appears to be a structural problem involving corroded steam pipes that run from floor to ceiling in every unit.  As a result it is impossible to sleep past 5:30 a.m., when the banging usually starts.  I wanted to know what actions I could take.  Does the problem amount to a violation of the covenant of habitability.  Should I pursue a case in housing court to have the problem corrected.  Can I have a plumber take a look at the problem and then deduct the cost of the etsimate or repairs from my rent?
: *******************
: It's probably not 'corroded pipes': it probably is bad pitch in the really big pipes in the basement.  My friend has that problem: some really @#%%$ licensed plumbers installed an elbow upside down, the racket is deafening, the landlord (a coop) won't fix it.  It wakes up the whole building if there was no heat overnight (otherwise it just wakes up the first two floors...)  The colder the pipes, the louder the noise.

: What you can do is organize your fellow tenants. Then together, if possible:  Write letters to the landlord.  Report the problem to both HPD and Dept of Buildings, boiler unit.  File a complaint with DHCR, ask for a rent reduction.  File an HP Action in Housing Court.  Learn how to do all this on TenantNet Home. 
: *******************
: : The other problem I am experiencing is that there is no live-in super in the building.  Instead, tenants are given the number of the person who handles the garbage and who occasionally performs light maintenance.  However, he ignores calls from tenants and will only respond to tenant complaints when the landlord directs him to.  For instance, he did come by when my kitchen roof collapsed and I reported it directly to the landlord.  However, he will not answer his beeper and he will not deal with problems such as leaky faucets, even when you ask him in person.  There used to be a live-in super in the building but he was fired and the landlord rented out his apartment.  Is it legal for the landlord not to have a super on the premises at an 11-unit building.  Is it sufficient to have someone who will only respond to emergencies and will not answer tenant complaints directly?  If this is not legal, can any action be taken by the tenants?
: *******************
: 9+ units = live-in or -nearby Super required, on call to tenants 24/7: it's the law.  See TenantNet Home, basic rights.  Report to HPD and DHCR (ask for rent reduction for reduction of services).


Optional Link URL:  
Link Title:         
Optional Image URL: 

---